The New Exchange

You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?



2/19/2017 9:11 am  #1


Betsy DeVoid off to a bad start

Looks like DeVoid's . . . Errrr I mean DeVos' . . . first visit to an actual school district as the secretary of education went over like the proverbial lead balloon. The reaction of teachers and administrators to DeVoid's comments after her visit are best summed up by the one teacher's comment that I emboldened.


Education Secretary DeVos criticized teachers at D.C. school she visited — and they're not having it

Emma Brown

Newly minted Education Secretary Betsy DeVos had a hard time getting inside the District of Columbia's Jefferson Middle School Academy last week when protesters briefly blocked her from entering. But at the end of her visit -- her first to a public school since taking office -- she stood on Jefferson's front steps and pronounced it "awesome."

A few days later, she seemed less enamored. The teachers at Jefferson were sincere, genuine and dedicated, she said; they seemed to be in "receive mode."

"They're waiting to be told what they have to do, and that's not going to bring success to an individual child," DeVos told a columnist for the conservative online publication Townhall. "You have to have teachers who are empowered to facilitate great teaching."

DeVos, who has no professional experience in public education, is an avowed proponent of voucher schools, charter schools, online schools and other alternatives to traditional public schools. Teachers across the country have been galled by what they see as her lack of faith in -- and understanding of -- the public schools that educate nearly nine in 10 of the nation's children.

'We fight back!': Protesters briefly block Betsy DeVos's visit to a D.C. school
Jefferson educators found her comments about their work hard to take: On Friday evening, the school responded to DeVos via its Twitter account, taking exception to the education secretary's characterization of Jefferson teachers.

"We're about to take her to school," the first of 11 rapid-fire tweets said.

The tweetstorm singled out teachers like Jessica Harris, who built Jefferson's band program "from the ground up," and Ashley Shepherd and Britany Locher, who not only teach students ranging from a first- to eighth-grade reading level, but also "maintain a positive classroom environment focused on rigorous content, humor, and love. They aren't waiting to be told what to do."

"JA teachers are not in a 'receive mode,'" the tweets concluded. "Unless you mean we 'receive' students at a 2nd grade level and move them to an 8th grade level."

An Education Department spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment. But DeVos weighed in on Twitter Saturday morning, saying Jefferson’s teachers are “awesome” and that they “deserve more freedom to innovate and help students."

Education Secretary Betsy DeVos is now being guarded by U.S. Marshals
D.C. Public Schools Chancellor Antwan Wilson, who accompanied DeVos on her visit to Jefferson, offered praise after the visit for the “dynamic classroom instruction” they both witnessed there.

Asked Saturday to respond to DeVos’s comments about Jefferson teachers, Wilson provided a statement:

I’ve worked in schools for my entire professional life — as a teacher, principal, and superintendent. I have learned from much experience what it takes to prepare students for college success. The teaching and learning at Jefferson will put our students on a path to college, successful careers, and beyond. I see that. Our teachers see that. Our students see that. And our parents see that. Defying expectations takes experience and a lifelong dedication to all students. DCPS is rich with educators who have this experience.

"I find it very interesting that the chancellor saw teachers that were pushing rigorous learning, students asking each other high-level questions and cultivating high-level responses, and teachers who take initiative and give their lives to the education of these children," said Jefferson teacher Caroline Hunt. "DeVos saw something so different. ... Maybe if DeVos knew more about education she would realize just how amazing the students, teachers and staff are."

Jefferson is five years into a turnaround effort and is one of the fastest-improving schools in the city's public school system. While fewer than half of students are meeting or approaching grade-level expectations, according to new Common Core tests, the school's growth has won it classification as a "rising" D.C. school.

Last edited by Rongone (2/19/2017 9:12 am)

 

2/19/2017 10:04 am  #2


Re: Betsy DeVoid off to a bad start

Considering that the teachers unions did all they could to stop her confirmation as Secretary of Education it's no surprise at the response to her visit. People did not want her at that school. If fact people blocked her first attempt to enter. They physically block her from gaining entrance. Her security team had to take her back to the vehicle and drive to another entrance. Because of the threats directed at her US Marshall's have been assigned to protect her! The union knows that school choice is coming and they are terrified.

Just read the last sentence in this article! This is the fastest-improving school in DC? Where half of the kids are not meeting or approaching grade level standards. Just another failing school system!

"Jefferson is five years into a turnaround effort and is one of the fastest-improving schools in the city's public school system. While fewer than half of students are meeting or approaching grade-level expectations, according to new Common Core tests, the school's growth has won it classification as a "rising" D.C. school."


 

Last edited by Common Sense (2/19/2017 10:05 am)


 “We hold these truths to be self-evident,”  former vice president Biden said during a campaign event in Texas on Monday. "All men and women created by — you know, you know, the thing.”

 
 

2/19/2017 10:09 am  #3


Re: Betsy DeVoid off to a bad start

Study: D.C. ranks near bottom of U.S. school systems
July 28, 2015
http://wtop.com/dc/2015/07/study-d-c-ranks-near-bottom-u-s-school-systems/
WASHINGTON — D.C. has the second to worst public school system in the United States, according to a new study from WalletHub, which analyzed dropout rates, math, reading and SAT scores, among other metrics.The city has the lowest math, reading and SAT scores of any school system in the U.S. It has the highest dropout rate and ranks last in school safety, according to the study.


The city’s graduation rate is disturbingly low, committee members reported: In 2014, the rate was 59 percent for public schools and 69 percent for charter schools. In the findings, the committee discovered low proficiency rates on math and science exams, and inadequate monitoring of English language learners and students with disabilities.
 

Last edited by Common Sense (2/19/2017 10:10 am)


 “We hold these truths to be self-evident,”  former vice president Biden said during a campaign event in Texas on Monday. "All men and women created by — you know, you know, the thing.”

 
 

2/19/2017 10:14 am  #4


Re: Betsy DeVoid off to a bad start

Common Sense wrote:

Considering that the teachers unions did all they could to stop her confirmation as Secretary of Education it's no surprise at the response to her visit. 



 

Betsy is completely unqualified for the position. That is why they don't want her.


We live in a time in which decent and otherwise sensible people are surrendering too easily to the hectoring of morons or extremists. 
 

2/19/2017 10:45 am  #5


Re: Betsy DeVoid off to a bad start

OK Common, here is what the job description of the department of education is:

When Congress created the Department in 1979, it declared these purposes:

to strengthen the Federal commitment to ensuring access to equal educational opportunity for every individual;
to supplement and complement the efforts of States, the local school systems and other instrumentalities of the States, the private sector, public and private educational institutions, public and private nonprofit educational research institutions, community-based organizations, parents, and students to improve the quality of education;
to encourage the increased involvement of the public, parents, and students in Federal education programs;
to promote improvements in the quality and usefulness of education through federally supported research, evaluation, and sharing of information;
to improve the coordination of Federal education programs;
to improve the management and efficiency of Federal education activities, especially with respect to the process, procedures, and administrative structures for the dispersal of Federal funds, as well as the reduction of unnecessary and duplicative burdens and constraints, including unnecessary paperwork, on the recipients of Federal funds; and
to increase the accountability of Federal education programs to the President, the Congress and the public. (Section 102, Public Law 96-88



Betsy DeVos has absolutely no, none, zilch, nada experience in education, teaching, administration, aid, substituting, coaching, virtually anything connected with schools other than fundraising for lobbying groups and elected officials that agree with her distorted point of view. Her main focus has been the dismantling of the public school system and replacing it with a mish-mash private, charter, and parochial schools. Her total disregard for the difficult job performed by public school teachers and administrations is evident due to her lack of actual experience in this area. Blaming the unionized teachers for the problems in public schooling is a red herring for her and others to hide behind because they refuse to put in the hard work necessary to aid in improving the public school system. DeVos' two faced handling of the situation detailed in the article I posted is further cause for concern on her ability to lead and direct the department of education. To praise the students, teachers, and administration as 'awesome' visiting the school only to later totally trash them all in her interview with Townhall is incomprehensible.

The bottom line is tha Ms. DeVos is unqualified to hold this office. Her focus on replacing public schooling for all with a system of private schools subsidized by the taxpayers, that does not require meeting certain educational norms, does not require verified certification of teachers, and does not hold administrators accountable for financial or academic standards is merely creating a shift and compounding of problems without offering solutions.

I wouldn't take my car to a McDonalds to get a mechanical problem rectified, and I wouldn't recommend a person totally devoid of any educational experience whatsoever to head the department of education. If it wasn't for the fact that she donated a lot of money to several senators re-election campaign coffers, she would have never been confirmed by the senate . . . Just ask Toomey.

     Thread Starter
 

2/19/2017 11:25 am  #6


Re: Betsy DeVoid off to a bad start

Her background certainly is not befitting of someone who needs to be in place in the DOE. 

Let's check back in 4 years and see how she and her team have done. 


"Do not confuse motion and progress, A rocking horse keeps moving but does not make any progress"
 
 

4/21/2017 10:51 am  #7


Re: Betsy DeVoid off to a bad start

DeVos continues to fail at the job, demonstrating the fact that she is totally unqualified for the position of secretary of education. Trump has made a lot of bad choices for his cabinet, but DeVos is one of the worst.


How is Betsy DeVos Bad for Public Education?

Let us count the ways.


Dana Hunter

Despite all our efforts, Betsy DeVos is the Secretary of Education. She's been on the job for several weeks now, and we've got a good idea of where she's taking America's public schools. In short: it's nowhere good.

So what has she been up to since she was confirmed?

She erased student debt protections against high fees charged to borrowers by guaranty agencies.

She installed a white woman as head of the department's Office for Civil Rights whose only real experience with civil rights law is 1) claiming she was discriminated against because she couldn't join a class section reserved for minorities and 2) writing an op-ed for the campus newspaper whining about affirmative action. Also, she apparently thinks women are only telling the truth about being sexually assaulted if they accuse a liberal man of attacking them.

She talked the talk about protecting trans students, but hasn't walked the walk. It's nice that she got language about LGBT students deserving protection from bullying, but it would've been nicer if she'd insisted they be allowed to use the bathroom that matches their gender identity. (You can join Laverne Cox's postcard writing campaign here.)

She's a huge proponent of the voucher programs that pour public money into private religious schools (yes, even the ones that use a terrible curriculum like ACE) – and this after it's been shown that voucher students "have fared worse academically compared to their closely matched peers attending public schools." Also, too, voucher programs are a great way to enable unscrupulous people to line their pockets with federal and state taxpayer money.

She paraded around at a STEM education event without mentioning the fact that Trump wants to eliminate NASA's education office, and the deep cuts his administration wants to make to her own Department of Education.

She blew off the concerns of undocumented students worried about Trump's anti-immigrant policies. She reassured them that Homeland Security Secretary John F. Kelley had said rounding up DREAMers wasn't a priority. Of course, "not a priority" doesn't mean "won't ever happen," and DREAMers are, in fact, being deported by this administration at an ever-increasing rate. So we can see exactly what her assurances are worth.

She's all aboard with a proposed budget that devastates successful public school programs while funneling public funds to vastly inferior private and for-profit schools. She's deluded enough to claim that this budget "protects 'the nation's most vulnerable populations.'" I don't think she understands what vulnerable populations are or what they actually need.

She's displayed more of her penny-wise-pound-foolish tendencies by scrapping Obama administration plans to streamline federal student loan management – meaning companies that have already screwed borrowers over can continue to do so, and many former students will end up not being told of all their options when they fall on hard times.

She thinks kids are lacking in "values and character development" education – a judgement most often wielded against minority and disadvantaged/disabled students, resulting in excessive and disproportionate discipline that can compromise or end their schooling.

She's sure that all of us who have been protesting her appointment aren't genuine. We're all supposedly shills sicced on her by her enemies. That's so precious.

She's excessively keen on making education a state and local affair – to the extent she'd prefer to eliminate the department she was confirmed to run.

She has family and financial ties to an organization that wants to abolish the Department of Education, reducing it to an advisory council. They also want the Ten Commandments to be displayed and Bible classes taught in all public schools, "promote instruction 'from a Judeo-Christian perspective,'" and envision a "gradual, voluntary return at all levels to free-market private schools, church schools, and home schools as the normative American practice." Comprehensive public education propelled us to the status of a world superpower, but these people want to return us to colonial times.

She founded (and provided much of the funding for) a group dedicated to promoting charter schools in Michigan, whose head thinks it's appropriate to talk about shaking the female state official who challenged him, just like he claims to do to his wife.

And she managed to insult dedicated public school teachers from the beginning.

Great work, Secretary DeVos. Really first class. For unaccountable private school values of "first class."

We have a lot of work to do in order to protect the free and comprehensive education every child in this country is entitled to. Our public schools are too precious to lose. Please let your representatives on the local, state, and federal levels know that you're watching, and you will hold them accountable for the decisions they make. And watch this space for ways to oppose Secretary DeVos's misguided mismanagement of our nation's schools.

     Thread Starter
 

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum