The New Exchange

You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

3/01/2015 7:43 am  #1

Can Christianity Survive in the Middle East?

Can Christianity Survive in the Middle East?

(CNN)Christianity was born in Bethlehem, in what's now the West Bank. It took root among people like the Assyrians, who flourished in ancient Mesopotamia. It soon found a home in places like modern-day Turkey.

In other words, Christianity traces its past squarely to the Middle East.

But do Christians have a future there?

Recent headlines provide ample evidence for skepticism. It's hard to ignore the depravity of ISIS beheading 21 Egyptian Christians on a beach in Libya. Nor can one shake off stories of women and children among the 262 Christians captured by ISIS in Syria, one of several horrors faced by Christians in that nation and neighboring Iraq.

They're not just feeling the heat from Islamic extremists: Just this week, police in Jerusalem said they suspected radical right-wing Israelis were to blame for defacing a Greek Orthodox seminary in Jerusalem with slurs maligning Jesus.

All this strain, all this chaos has shrunk the percentage of the Middle East's once-sizable population of openly practicing Christians.

While no one is saying what's happening -- especially given the savagery of ISIS -- isn't alarming, that doesn't make it surprising. The Middle East has changed a lot since the first millennium A.D. for Christians. It has also changed a lot over the past century: The percentage of Christians relative to the Mideast's overall population has gone from 13.6% in 1910 to 4.2% in 2010, and it's expected to drop even further, according to religious demographers Todd Johnson and Gina Zurlo.

"What we're seeing right now," said Baylor University historical theologian Philip Jenkins, "is the latest phase of something that has been going for 100 years, pretty much."

Christians flood Gulf nations, but not always openly
This isn't to say Christianity itself is dying out.

It is growing in places like Africa, Asia, South America and -- believe it or not -- some of the most dogmatic, restrictive nations in the Middle East.

This is thanks to migrants who travel from places like the Philippines and Africa to oil-rich countries where Islam is a state-sponsored faith. According to the World Religion Database, places like Qatar and Bahrain have seen their Christian ranks surge from basically nothing a century ago to 10% and 13% of their respective populations.

Some of these countries are relatively permissive. The United Arab Emirates lets Christians do most everything but evangelize, for example, and Bahrain has top Christian and Jewish officials.

On the other end of the spectrum is Saudi Arabia, which doesn't allow the practice of anything but Islam. Religious police in Saudi Arabia try to make sure that's the case. David Curry, whose nonprofit group Open Doors USA helps persecuted Christians in more than 60 countries, calls Saudi Arabia's control on religious matters "complete."

"You're not allowed to go to church, you're not allowed to have a Bible, you're not allowed to think for yourself," Curry said.

Yet that hasn't stopped Christians from coming for a simple reason: jobs. They'll likely keep coming, with the World Religion Database projecting Saudi Arabia will have more than 1.5 million Christians by 2025.

And they don't necessarily stop believing and professing their faith once they cross the border.

"There are home churches (where people are) practicing their faith in private," says Zurlo, who helps manage the database and is assistant director of the Center for the Study of Global Christianity. "... Some of them come as guest workers, but they see themselves as missionaries."

'I expect Christians in Iraq will be gone'
Still, such migrant workers are in the shadows and under threat of deportation, and more, if caught praying openly or communally. They haven't been in the Middle East long, and there's no guarantee any one of them will stay long, either.

That's in contrast to other Christian communities that have been in the Middle East for centuries.

They're people like Assyrians, whose ancestors were part a cradle of modern civilization. They began converting to Christianity within years of Jesus' death and have kept the faith despite the growth of Islam in their homeland and, most shockingly, the Assyrian genocide of the 1910s and early 1920s.

Now those Assyrians in Iraq and Syria are under fire again.

Last August, ISIS militants overran Qaraqosh, a historic Assyrian community of about 50,000 people and Iraq's largest Christian city. And in recent days, the terrorist group stormed Assyrian villages in northeastern Syria, taking some 262 people hostage, said Assyrian Human Rights Network founder Osama Edward. Others fled for their lives, including about 600 taking refuge in St. Mary's Cathedral in al-Hasakah, Syria.

"We pray, we pray all the time," Romel David, who has 12 relatives thought to be among those kidnapped, told CNN affiliate KCRA. "What we've heard is it was like a sea of black uniforms marching through all the villages, burning down the churches, desecrating the crosses and wreaking havoc."

ISIS has targeted other Christians in the region as well, like those in Mosul, Iraq, who were told last July to convert to Islam, pay a fine or face "death by sword." Curry calls ISIS' actions against Christians "genocide." Yet it shouldn't obscure the fact that, even before this group's emergence, the number of Iraqi Christians was on the decline.

Some of that is due to a weak Iraqi central government and general instability. Christians might also be hurt by their historic affiliation with the Baath Party, once led by deposed Saddam Hussein (with the Syrian branch led by embattled President Bashar al-Assad). Another factor is the rise of militias and politicians who make Islam more central to their missions, to the exclusion of others.

Curry, from Open Doors USA, said Iraq had about 1.5 million Christians just over a decade ago. That number is now under 150,000, something that he attributes to family influences, government actions, communal pressure and targeted violence from militant groups.

"In 10 years from now," Jenkins added, "I expect Christians in Iraq will be gone."

Expert: Change in Muslim world needed to help Christians
A Pew Research Center report released this week found that, in 2013, that Christians faced harassment in 102 countries. Muslims got similar treatment in 99 nations, and Jews faced harassment in 77, a seven-year high.

Five of the 18 countries with "very high government restrictions on religion" were in the Mideast, according to the same study. That means that groups like Christians have a tough time in that region, but it's not the only place nor are they the only ones persecuted. And there isn't anything novel about people of one faith being pitted against another.

Religious conflict is not something that's new to the 21st century.
Religious demographer Gina Zurlo

Still, even when strife involves people from different religions, that doesn't mean the discord is all about faith. It can also be about power, with leaders using religion in part to curry popular support and lure recruits. Jenkins notes a "combination of religious hatred and organized crime" is particularly dangerous, as when hostages are held for ransom or "tax" revenues are solicited from minorities. When this happens, any "other" group -- Christians included -- can become a target.

ISIS and its leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, are prime examples. Religion for them is almost a means to an end, as a way to create a sense of superiority, rationalize violence and spawn an "us vs. them" mentality while reaping rewards and amassing territory, said John Esposito, the founder of Georgetown University's Prince Alwaleed Bin Talal Center for Muslim-Christian Understanding.

"You appeal to religion both to legitimize what you're doing and to mobilize people," Esposito said.

Some of it likely can't be helped, according to Zurlo. With or without ISIS, their number will continue to fall -- something the Massachusetts-based religious demographer asserts is "not very unusual in the history of Christianity."

"Christianity has a serial nature: It goes in an area and it thrives, then it (declines)," Zurlo said. "It thrived in the Middle East for a very long time."

According to Esposito, one key to slowing this drop or, at least, to making life easier for those Christians who want to be in the Mideast is changing the Muslim world. A vast majority of Muslims denounce extremists like ISIS, but there are still enough who join such groups because they're angry at their government or others and do not feel they have any better outlet or purpose. When that happens, it's bad for Christians.

"To prevent the recruits, you have to get at the root causes," said Esposito, a former consultant to U.S. and other governments. "And even if you wipe out ISIS, unless those conditions change, you're going to have other groups that emerge."

We live in a time in which decent and otherwise sensible people are surrendering too easily to the hectoring of morons or extremists. 

3/01/2015 8:47 am  #2

Re: Can Christianity Survive in the Middle East?

 'Sooner or later, everything old is new again.' 

"Do not confuse motion and progress, A rocking horse keeps moving but does not make any progress"

3/02/2015 4:58 pm  #3

Re: Can Christianity Survive in the Middle East?

This has all gone so wrong.

Faith was just supposed to be a way to make you less afraid.  To help you understand your place in things.

Something to make yourself a better person.  A personal relationship with your god.

It was never meant to be a standard by which you judge others.

Why can't people just hold their faith in their hearts?

If you make yourself miserable trying to make others happy that means everyone is miserable.

-Me again


3/03/2015 11:22 am  #4

Re: Can Christianity Survive in the Middle East?

+1 for post #13. 

And the answer to your question may be - because their heads get in the way.


3/03/2015 3:31 pm  #5

Re: Can Christianity Survive in the Middle East?

CT nailed it.  I could not have said it better.  The more I study organized religion, the more I'm driven to atheism.


3/03/2015 3:39 pm  #6

Re: Can Christianity Survive in the Middle East?

Nah Fred, don't let humans ruin the divine. People always tend to pervert the pure. Every time I start to feel the way you do, I start to remind myself of all the faults of the human race, then about a third of the way into the list I decide that humans don't know squat. I guess that makes me more in favor of unorganized religion. 


3/03/2015 4:11 pm  #7

Re: Can Christianity Survive in the Middle East?

I dunno, Fred. Disdain for organized religion should, if anything, sour you on organized religion.
Atheism hinges on whether you believe in God, not what man says about God.

We live in a time in which decent and otherwise sensible people are surrendering too easily to the hectoring of morons or extremists. 
     Thread Starter

3/03/2015 7:10 pm  #8

Re: Can Christianity Survive in the Middle East?

I dunno, Fred. Disdain for organized religion should, if anything, sour you on organized religion.
Atheism hinges on whether you believe in God, not what man says about God.
  -  Goose

Ok, let's suppose I believe god exists.  Now what?  It's a free-for-all and everybody, including me, can decide who or what god is for themselves?

Actually, I can live with that as long as everyone realizes they may be wrong and keep an open mind that god may be a human invention and didn't exist until our species showed with the desire to explain what they didn't understand at the time.

Last edited by Just Fred (3/03/2015 10:32 pm)


3/03/2015 8:00 pm  #9

Re: Can Christianity Survive in the Middle East?

'god may be a human invention and didn't exist until our species showed with the desire to explain what they didn't understand at the time'. - Just Fred said

Ooooo, the chicken or the egg argument. No one will win that one.

Last edited by BYOB (3/03/2015 8:01 pm)


3/09/2015 2:29 pm  #10

Re: Can Christianity Survive in the Middle East?

You mean like longer than 2000 years?

I think it will survive.

By the way, you can go to most any western embassy or consulate in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and attend private religious services of other religious denominations. Prosthelitizing, evangelical, or open religious activity other than Islam will get you in trouble. Usually resulting in having your visa revoked and expulsion from the country.


Board footera


Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum